Easy Popovers Recipe in a Muffin Pan

While regular yeast rolls have their place at holiday gatherings, these Easy Popovers are on a whole new level. They are crispy on the outside with soft, airy centers perfect for sopping up the last bit of gravy.

Once you serve these bad boys, it’s over. You’ll be expected to make them by the dozen every year, but thankfully for you and me, the recipe is a cinch to make and requires no yeast or kneading.

Hosting a holiday feast is no easy task, but with a few years under my belt, I can finally have everything ready by noon AND greet my guests in full attire. 

How? I’ve got it down to a science with my Giving Thanks, a holiday menu, with 23 fall-inspired recipes to choose from, a daily prep guide, and an hourly recipe queue for Thanksgiving day so everything gets baked, roasted, assembled, and cooked before the guests show up.

And you’ll find these Easy Popovers along with recipes for Perfect Roasted Turkey, roasted fall vegetables, and Cornbread Dressing with Sausage.

What is a Popover?

If you’ve never tried popovers, you are in for a treat. They are a light roll made from egg batter that “pops over” the muffin tin, giving the top a blossomed appearance. Inside their crispy, golden-brown exteriors, the centers are hollow and pull-apart soft with a buttery flavor.

If that description isn’t enough to convince you of their superiority to yeast rolls, here are a few reasons why these will be the first item to disappear:

1. They melt in your mouth when served hot with butter.
2. They’re soft, airy perfection.
3. Perfect for soaking up gravy or cranberry sauce.
4. Everyone loves bread.
5. They’re easy and quick to bake!
6. It’s a holiday tradition, and I’m passing it down to you.

Popover Ingredients

It’s hard to imagine 5 simple ingredients could create something so delicious and wonderful, but good thing they do. Here’s everything needed to make them:

• melted butter: unsalted is best
• eggs
• milk: regular whole milk works best
• all-purpose flour
• salt

How to Make Popovers in a Muffin Pan

Typically, popovers are made in a special pan with deeper cups that allow them to “popover,” hence the name. However, we’re going to use a regular muffin pan to make this recipe. There’s no need to buy a special pan that you will use at most; twice a year.

And to simplify the process, the batter is whipped up in a blender. I’ve found it to be easier and yield better results than whisking. Here’s how to make these easy popovers: 

1. Prep
   Preheat the oven to 400F, grease a 12 muffin cup tin with tablespoons butter, and place it in the oven to warm for 5 minutes. 
2. Blend
   Meanwhile, add the eggs to a blender and blend at medium-high speed. Add the milk and blend until smooth. 
3. Blend some more
   Add the flour, salt, and remaining butter to the egg-milk mixture, and blend until smooth. 
4. Pour the batter
   Carefully remove the warmed muffin pan and pour the batter into the muffin cups filling them only ¾th of the way. *Keep in mind these are going to rise and expand.  
5. Watch them rise
   Baked for 35 minutes or until golden brown. Remove from the oven and serve. 

Once you catch a glimpse of these popovers rising to their golden brown glory in the oven, you’ll be hooked. 

Since we don’t want any fights breaking out over who gets the last popover, it’s good practice to double the recipe. All you need is two muffin pans, and you’re good to go!

The Key to Perfect Popovers with Extra Rise

The perfect popover is super light and has a crispy exterior. Below are simple tips to achieve those desired results batch after batch: 

Room temperature ingredients
Starting with room temperature eggs and milk allows the ingredients to emulsify into a smooth, thin batter so that the popovers can rise easily. 

Allow the batter to rest
At least 15 minutes gives time for the gluten to relax, creating a more flexible batter. Flexible batter = tall and fluffy popovers. 

Don’t disturb
Once the popovers are in the oven, don’t open! This could cause them to deflate. 

Let the steam escape
Once you remove them from the oven, remove them from the pan immediately. Otherwise, they’ll continue to cook and lose that crispy exterior. 

More Tips for Perfect, Easy Popovers

So know that we have the basics down, all that’s left is some yummy variations and serving tips which I share with you below. 

Stir in seasonings
Add 1 ½ teaspoons of your favorite herb or seasoning blend. I love Italian and Herbs de Provence.  

Add cheese
Stir in 1 cup shredded Cheddar, Parmesan, or Gouda cheese into the blended batter. It brings these popovers to a heavenly level. 

Make them sweet and savory
Sprinkle the tops with cinnamon and sugar, or serve with your favorite jam and butter. 

Serve them fresh
As with homemade biscuits and bread, popovers are best served straight from the oven. Of course, you can reheat them in a 350F oven for 5 minutes or until warm, but nothing beats that first fresh-out of the oven experience. 

Can you make the batter ahead? 
You can make the batter beforehand, but I recommend no more than an hour. 

My Tips to a Succesful Thanksgiving Dinner:

• Plan the menu and delegate dishes to the family members and friends.
• Start weeks ahead with the prep work. Anything that can be made ahead or prepped, DO IT!
• On Thanksgiving day, before you get anything started, get yourself ready. Trust me.

In case you are hosting your first Thanksgiving or need some fresh menu ideas to host this year, you’ll find what you need inside my Thanksgiving Menu. Simple recipes like these popovers are exactly what you’ll find inside.

Of course, I have a full Thanksgiving Guide to hosting Thanksgiving so make sure to check that post out.

Since we don’t want any fights breaking out over who gets the last popover, this recipe is easily doubled. All you need is two muffin pans and you’re good to go!

Print